The 49ers May Have Cost Themselves The Super Bowl For Not Understanding The Playoff Overtime Rules

Kyle Shannahan 49ers Super Bowl
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

If you were confused when Super Bowl LVIII hurtled toward overtime on Sunday night and weren’t 100% sure what the precise rules were, you weren’t alone. In fact, the San Francisco 49ers, one of the teams on the actual field at Allegiant Stadium, were largely clueless about what said rules were.

San Francisco fullback Kyle Juszczyk spoke about how unclear the recently-changed rule book was on playoff overtime — and he was far from the only 49ers player who grasped at straws for clarity.

Head coach Kyle Shanahan is taking a lot of heat for choosing to receive the ball first after winning the OT coin toss. It turns out, for as detail-oriented as Shanahan and the 49ers’ entire operation has been to play in the NFC Championship Game in four of the last five years, this was something they were not fully prepared for, per a feature on The Ringer:

In case those screen grabs are a little inconclusive, Chiefs star defensive lineman Chris Jones said the Chiefs were talking through overtime in the postseason in training camp. Part of the reason the rules were changed stems from Kansas City’s own, thrilling OT duel in the Divisional Round against the Bills a while back. They were the reason the rules changed, so to be fair, they had a bit of a built-in advantage that way.

Meanwhile, Juszczyk’s confusion is on the video above; Arik Armstead only saw the new rules on the jumbotron at Allegiant Stadium and was ignorant of them otherwise. That’s a tough look for the 49ers franchise to say the least, and you can’t help but look to Shanahan as the man to blame. His record in the Super Bowl is getting pretty out of hand.

You can say “Shanahan always blows the lead” but it didn’t feel like that last night necessarily. Getting beat by Patrick Mahomes’ Chiefs isn’t the most shameful defeat ever. It’s just losing to superior, almost unprecedented greatness. There’s also the X-factor of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. Come on now.

Kansas City is just built different. What else can you say when you see a stat like this?

LOL. How stupid is that? And I mean that as a supreme compliment.

Here’s what Shanahan had to say about overtime in the aftermath of a crushing 25-22 defeat:

This was only the second Super Bowl ever to go past the fourth quarter. With how dangerous Mahomes is standing on the opposite sideline, I can’t blame Shanahan for getting a little shaken. Plus, he had a dynamic defensive coordinator to match wits with in Steve Spagnuolo, not to mention a quarterback of his own in Brock Purdy who’s just not in the same galaxy as Mahomes from a physical tools standpoint.

Sometimes, when you have such a demoralizing loss like this, there aren’t any obvious takeaways. I guess I’d rather come painfully close to the Lombardi Trophy than get blown off the field. At least the 49ers put up a good fight. Their defense had a number of chances to get stops, and even had a 4th and short on KC’s winning drive. One tackle for loss there, and San Francisco is throwing a Super Bowl parade.

Yes, the overtime could’ve been handled better by Shanahan and the Niners as a whole. At the end of the night, one team had Mahomes and the other didn’t. To me, that is and will continue to be the real difference between these two teams who seem to have a stranglehold on their respective conferences.

A beer bottle on a dock



A beer bottle on a dock