Gotta prop up those SEC teams…
It’s hard to believe we’re nearing the end of the college football regular season, but we’re just a couple of weeks away from finding out which teams are going to compete in the College Football Playoffs, in the final year of the 12-team bracket.
And it seems like that bracket’s going to include a lot of SEC teams.
The newest rankings were released yesterday, with Georgia at #1 and Utah at #2 as virtual locks for the playoff. And both of those teams make sense: Georgia has only one loss this season (although it’s an inexplicable loss to Auburn), while Utah is sitting at 10-0 with a real shot at sailing into the playoffs undefeated.
But it seems like it’s the #3 team that’s causing the most controversy with the committee’s rankings.
The Alabama Crimson Tide are sitting at #3 in the rankings for a second straight week, despite being 8-2 with losses to Georgia and Tennessee so far this season, and despite struggling against Vanderbilt early in this past weekend’s game before ultimately coming out of Nashville with an unimpressive 21-0 win.
That puts the Tide over undefeated UCLA, who scored a win over Oregon earlier this season, and one-loss teams like Notre Dame, Miami, Indiana, BYU, and Wake Forest.
In fact, the reigning national champion Indiana Hoosiers are currently ranked 9th by the committee after dropping five spots last week – during their bye week. The committee’s reasoning for dropping them that far when they didn’t play? It was because all of their opponents that they had beaten previously ended up losing last week, making Indiana’s win seem less impressive.
But what happened this week while Alabama was struggling with a mediocre Vanderbilt team? All of their opponents that they had been previously ended up losing: LSU fell to Texas, Texas A&M was embarrassed by was embarrassed by Tennessee, Mississippi State continued to be the laughingstock of the SEC now that their quarterback Kamario Taylor is out, Kentucky lost to Florida, and even South Carolina lost to Arkansas.
Every single one of Alabama’s wins became less impressive this week – yet the committee still didn’t penalize them for it like they did Indiana.
Notre Dame also dropped a spot to #6, getting jumped by Texas, despite the Irish scoring an impressive 41-7 win over Boston College while Texas managed to pull out a last second win over LSU, which dropped the Tigers out of the rankings entirely.
How did the committee justify dropping Notre Dame through no fault of their own? Well according to CFP committee chair Hunter Yurachek, it’s all about Texas’ strength of schedule and beating what was, at the time, a top 25 team:
“Notre Dame did all they could. They beat Boston College, 41-7. I think they had 500 yards of total offense. They held Boston College, I think, to less than 150 yards of total offense. It wasn’t anything that Notre Dame did.
It was Texas having an impressive win at one of our top-25 teams in LSU, and it really gave Texas the nod over Notre Dame. Plus, that would have been, if the rankings held, Texas’s fifth win over a top-25 team. A couple of those teams fell out of the rankings, but that’s significant strength of schedule for Texas as compared to Notre Dame.”
And we also have to talk about the bottom of the rankings: Four of the final five teams to make the top 25 come from…you guessed it, the SEC. The committee has FOUR 6-4 SEC teams in the top 25, including South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss. (This means that, if the playoff were already expanded to 24 like it will be next year, we’d have as many as EIGHT teams from the SEC in the playoffs, according to the committee’s rankings).
Even some analysts believe the teams at the bottom of the field are ranked as a way to boost the resume of SEC teams:
How does the committee explain the #3 spot for Alabama? Yurachek attempted to explain:
“I think it’s a collection of things for Alabama. Not only the margin of wins, their SEC wins, which is close to 23 points a game, but their relative scoring defense is in the top 20, relative scoring offense is in the top 5, record strength is in the top 5. Quite honestly, when we watch them on film, when we watch their games, we really feel like they’re one of the best three or four teams in the country.”
Unfortunately for the committee though, it doesn’t seem that fans are buying it.
Given the seemingly inflated rankings of many teams in the SEC, fans erupted after the rankings to accuse the committee of having an SEC bias:
Now, why would people think the committee has an SEC bias? Well ESPN, which has the rights to broadcast the College Football Playoff, also has the media rights for the SEC. And let’s take a look at who makes up the playoff committee:
8 committee members with ties to the conference. Surely there’s no funny business going on…
Well ESPN analyst Heather Dinich tried to explain away the SEC bias from the committee by explaining that…they’re simply using a new metric this year that entirely favors the SEC:
So a loss to Arkansas is more valuable than a win in another conference because the SEC is a stronger conference overall? And they’re only taking into account league games to determine that strength of conference? I think I speak for everybody (except Alabama fans) when I say they should throw that metric in the garbage.
What a mess. Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear that the committee cares, and probably won’t until one of these schools from another conference files a lawsuit against the committee. Because that’s how things are really settled in college football these days: Not on the field, at least based on the rankings, but in the courtroom.





