“The Challenge To Television Is That” – Why Taylor Sheridan Says Quentin Tarantino Was Right To Call ‘Yellowstone’ A Soap Opera

Jamie and Beth Dutton Yellowstone
Yellowstone/Paramount Network

Legendary filmmaker, Quentin Tarantino, once said that Yellowstone was “just a soap opera.” Taylor Sheridan just confirmed that to be true.

You’d be hard pressed to find a more prolific and successful creator than Sheridan. He’s the mind behind countless hits for Paramount+, and soon, he’ll be taking his talents over to NBCUniversal to make TV shows (and some movies) for them instead. Sheridan will add to an already impressive resume of hits, like Landman, The Madison, and the one that arguably started it all: Yellowstone.

The Kevin Costner-led western drama was a sensation when it was on television, and it had a great, five-season run (some might say it limped to the finish line). Fans still swear by the show, saying it’s some of the best TV that’s been created in the 21st century. Most will agree… but Quentin Tarantino did liken it to a soap opera.

During a 2024 interview with Joe Rogan on The Joe Rogan Experience, the filmmaker (and actor) responsible for bringing such great films as Pulp Fiction, Inglorious Bastards, and Once Upon A Time In Hollywood to the silver screen said that TV had really started giving films a run for their money.

He ended up using Taylor Sheridan’s hit western drama as an example in his argument, but by the end of his thought, Tarantino kind of wrote off the Sheridan-created show:

“I’ll use Yellowstone. I didn’t really get around to watching Yellowstone the first three years or so, and then I watched the first season and I went, ‘Wow this is f**king great. I’ve always been a big Kevin Costner fan. He’s wonderful in this.’ I got really caught up in the show and all of the sudden I’m having a good time and I’ve got a couple of seasons I haven’t seen so I’m watching it.

In the first season, I’m like, ‘This is like a big movie.’ So I end up watching three seasons of it, and I watch that 1883 (spinoff) and say, ‘Oh this is a good western show.’ Then, after I’ve watched two of three seasons or one season of 1883… while I’m watching it, I’m compelled. But at the end of the day, it’s just a soap opera.

You don’t remember it five years from now. You are caught up in the minutia of the moment. The difference is I’ll see a good western movie and I’ll remember it for the rest of my life. I’ll remember this scene or that scene and it built to an emotional climax of some degree… There’s not a payoff on this (TV) stuff. There’s just more inter-connectional drama.”

The respected director backed up his point of view by pointing out that once you get to know the characters, the back stories and all of their connection points… it just turns into a repetitive, soap-opera-like program. Tarantino even went as far to say that people won’t remember it five years from now (he said that in 2024), which is a stretch if you ask me.

I always wondered if Taylor Sheridan ever saw that critique, and how he would respond to it. He’s not one to give into the opinions of critics, but this is Quentin Tarantino we’re talking about here.

Sure enough, in a recent interview with Yahoo Finance, Sheridan discussed the challenges that come with creating TV shows versus films, and he mentioned the exact quote from Tarantino:

“You know, it’s funny because the challenge to television is that at some point, and Quentin Tarantino said this about my show, and he is right, at some point it becomes a soap opera. Unless it is closed-ended like ‘1883.’

That’s what I learned from ‘Yellowstone.’ At some point it’s going to become repetitious. We can only say, ‘Don’t take my land, I want your land’ so many times. Only so many people can show up to take the land.”

Evidently, Sheridan didn’t take the comment harshly. Instead, he saw it as a learning moment, and now has a better set of guidelines to take to his shows that are currently still in the middle of their respective stories.

It’s a good rule for the TV creator to have, but fans might not love hearing it:

“I think that about the longest you can have a show run without it becoming repetitive is about five years. And that’s what we did on ‘Yellowstone.’”

In other words, don’t expect shows like Landman or The Madison to roll on past five seasons. If you need proof that Sheridan really means that, his incredibly underrated show, Mayor of Kingstown, is coming back for a fifth and final season next year. There seems to be a five-season cap for Sheridan’s projects… and we now know that’s by design.

A beer bottle on a dock

STAY ENTERTAINED

A RIFF ON WHAT COUNTRY IS REALLY ABOUT

A beer bottle on a dock