Luke Bryan & Jason Aldean Deny Being On The Hook For $1.4 Million Over Now-Closed Nashville Steakhouse

Jason Aldean Adam LaRoche Luke Bryan
E3 Chophouse

Not their responsibility.

That’s the response from Luke Bryan, Jason Aldean, and former MLB player Adam LaRoche to a $1.4 million lawsuit filed by the former landlord for their now-closed Nashville steakhouse, E3 Chophouse.

The original E3 Chophouse in Steamboat Springs, Colorado was opened by LaRoche and his brothers in 2013, and in 2019 the former MLB player joined with Jason Aldean and Luke Bryan to open their location in Nashville’s Hillsboro Village. At the time, LaRoche praised the country stars for their involvement in bringing the restaurant to Music City:

“Jason & Luke jokingly talked for years about opening an E3 Chophouse in Nashville, and over time those talks became more serious. This is the town they call home, and they’re directly involved in the development and design of the restaurant. It’s come a long way from Luke wearing the E3 hat I made as a novelty many years ago, and we are humbled and excited to bring the restaurant to Music City.”

But the Nashville location abruptly closed their doors back in February following the Valentine’s Day weekend, announcing the move as a “temporary pause” in a post on social media:

“We’re temporarily pausing operations as we evaluate what Nashville needs next.

Our team is assessing market opportunities and exploring potential rebrand and re-concept strategies for the future of this location.”

Well despite calling it a pause, it definitely sounds permanent, because not long after the closure a lawsuit was filed by the landlord, Village 21 Properties, against Outlaws, LLC, the company that entered into the lease agreement for the restaurant. And back in June, an amended complaint was filed to add Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche as defendants to the lawsuit.

According to the complaint, back in 2018 Outlaws, LLC signed a 10-year lease that was set to run through August 31, 2029 to use the building “solely for the purpose of the operation of an E3 Chophouse.” The complaint alleges that Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche were included in the lease as guarantors.

The lawsuit claims that E3 Chophouse failed to pay rent for January and February 2026, before ceasing operations on February 19 without giving notice to the landlord. A tax lien was also issued against the business on November 3, 2025 for unpaid taxes.

After the steakhouse failed to pay any rent in 2026, the landlord says that they sent notice on March 19 informing them that their lease would be terminated and demanding that E3 surrender the property by March 25, but that the steakhouse failed to vacate the building by the deadline.

The landlord filed a lawsuit in March for unlawful detainer, and a court ordered the steakhouse to turn over possession of the building to the landlord. But no representatives of E3 Chophouse attended a follow-up hearing to determine damages owed to the landlord, so a default judgment was entered against the restaurant in the amount of $1,427,135.54.

The steakhouse immediately appealed, but the landlord responded by filing an amended complaint seeking to add Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche personally to the lawsuit as guarantors of the debt, claiming that they breached their duty to guaranty the lease and are responsible for the damages alongside Outlaw, LLC.

The owners, though, claim the contract says otherwise.

In a motion for summary judgment, which was obtained and reviewed by Whiskey Riff, the trio of owners including Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche claim that the landlord’s interpretation of the guaranty is inaccurate and that they’re actually on the hook for far less than the $1.4 million being sought.

According to the response, Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche executed a limited guaranty of Outlaws, LLC’s lease agreement, which made them personally responsible for the payments to the landlord, a total of $2.5 million for rent for the entire 10-year lease. They were also responsible for construction costs, which were amortized over 10 years.

But according to that contract, their obligation for the rent payments lasted for only 5 years, which means the guaranty for the rent expired before the steakhouse ended up breaking the lease. That means Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche would only personally be on the hook for the unamortized portion of the construction costs – which they claim is a total of only $19,585.60 each, much less than the $1.4 million the landlord is seeking to recover from the high-profile owners.

So far no response has been filed by the landlord, but there’s no doubt that they will oppose the request for summary judgment, since it would dismiss the claim for the rent against Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche and leave only the portion of the construction costs that’s not in dispute.

If the owners are right though, the landlord may be out of luck.

A beer bottle on a dock

STAY ENTERTAINED

A RIFF ON WHAT COUNTRY IS REALLY ABOUT

A beer bottle on a dock